Heart Pencil Arrow Valentines + Printable Gift Tag

This post and its photos may contain Amazon or other affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Arrow Pencil Valentine's Day Gift Idea

This post may contain affiliate links. I will receive a small commission from these sales at no additional cost to you!

I love Valentine’s Day, and I especially love creating sweet gifts for my boys and their friends. I wanted to focus on making a non-candy Valentine treat since our homeschool group does a sugar-free celebration, and I came up with these adorable heart arrow pencils + a printable “You’ve got the write stuff, Valentine!” card.

FREE PRINTABLE Heart Pencil Arrow Valentines

How to Make Pencil Arrow Valentines Day Treats

All it takes to create these cute arrows are holiday pencils, Duck Tape, paper and glue! To create the arrow’s feathers, I folded a strip of Duck Tape around the eraser end of the pencil and cut it to shape with non-stick Duck Tape Scissors (one of the handiest tools ever!).

Ellison AllStar SuperStar Machine

Glitter paper is perfect for the heart arrow tips, and there’s no quicker way to cut loads of glitter hearts than with my Ellison AllStar SuperStar machine! I used the 4-Up Hearts die #A10644 (one of my favorites!) because they’re the ideal size for this project.

Cutting Heart with the Ellison Sizzix Machine

I can crank out tons of these sparkly hearts in just a few minutes! A dab of hot glue is used to attach the hearts to the tip of the pencil.

Two heart-tipped arrows made from pencils and colored tape with Valentine card

I added a “You’ve got the ‘write’ stuff, Valentine!” card tied on with some red and white baker’s twine. Quick, easy, and totally adorable!

Heart Arrow Pencils for Valentine's Day

I’m smitten with these darling non-candy treats!

Heart Pencil Arrows for Valentine's Day
Non-Candy Valentine's Day Idea

The kids think they’re pretty cool, too!

Valentine Heart Pencil Arrows

These sweet heart pencil arrows take just a few minutes to create, and you can pass them out to all of your friends for under $5 per classroom!

Get the You’ve Got the Write Stuff Cards Here

You've Got the Write Stuff Valentine Printable

To get the You’ve Got the Write Stuff Cards, enter your name and email address into the form below and click the “GET IT NOW” button!

Files are for PERSONAL USE ONLY!


Can’t find the download form? Having trouble with the file? Check out our Digital Downloads FAQ page for answers to the most common troubleshooting questions!

Image of text that says Heidi

Check Out These Other Valentine’s Day Printables!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *